A refresh makes sense when the site still reflects what you sell and the problems are concentrated in a few places. A full redesign makes sense when the site’s structure, message, or platform makes it hard for customers to understand the business you run today.
Refresh when you know which pages need work
You may have useful service pages already and need better photos, clearer copy, a more useful homepage, or a shorter inquiry form. If your team can make those changes in the current platform and the navigation still serves customers, keep the foundation. Use the existing site to test a sharper offer or a clearer next step on one important page.
Rebuild when the problems are connected
If your most important service is buried, the site is hard to update, or mobile users struggle across multiple pages, the work may extend beyond a refresh. A rebuild is also worth considering when you need a new way to organize lots of content. Heartwood Kitchen & Bath needed browsable product collections and dedicated paths for homeowners and contractors. Those needs shaped how the site was organized.
Keep what already brings customers in
Look at the pages that get relevant search traffic, earn links, or regularly start conversations. Keep their URLs where practical. If a page moves, map the old address to its closest replacement and test the redirect. Update links on your site, check your contact and tracking flows, and monitor the migration in Google Search Console after launch.
Scope the work before asking for a price
List the pages that need updating, how much copy you already have, who will provide images, and any forms, scheduling tools, or CMS content the site needs. Include the jobs your team needs to do on the site after launch. Those details tell you far more about the scope than a page count on its own.
For help scoping it, read What Does a Website Redesign Cost?, see Website Design & Redesign, or request a Business Review.